River City Select

Baroque Brass Festival Vivaldi Photo

Baroque Brass Festival Vivaldi Picture

Baroque Brass Festival Vivaldi Photo

Baroque Brass Festival Vivaldi Image

Most helpful customer reviews

11 of 13 people found the following review helpful.
Excellent Baroque collection – everyone should have this!
By Andrew Furst
This is a remarkable collection of Baroque music. I’ve heard a lot of Baroque music and I am very discriminating about performance and sound quality. This set is a winner and a fantastic bargain… Somehow they’ve managed to choose what is truly “best” from the period (for example I’ve always felt Bach’s Brandenburg Concertos # 2, 3, 5 were the best of the six, while 1,4,6 were relatively weaker – and lo and behold this collection includes 2,3,and 5) while missing very little if anything that “should have” been here (of course a 10 or 12 CD collection would have been even better, but you have to stop somewhere).

The performances here are excellent, and the recording quality is very high. I disagree with the person who claims this isn’t “audiophile quality”, because I don’t think it could get much better unless it were on another medium such as SACD. I didn’t particularly notice coughing on Handel’s “Messiah” but Messiah fans would likely prefer a complete performance of that particular work anyway (the excerpts from Messiah here are complete pieces, but this set doesn’t include the entire 2 hour or whatever Messiah). These do not sound like “outtakes”, what kind of a comment is that? Somebody worked very hard to put this collection together, and they did a fantastic job (and I have zero affiliation with this, I just feel the truth as I see it should be told).

Vivaldi’s “Four Seasons” is presented in it’s entirety (ok, it’s not the entire Vivaldi Opus 8, but it is the entire Four Seasons as normally found on any “Four Seasons” CD). There are so many great works here, which a lot of people will recognize even if they didn’t know the actual piece or composer (or even that it was from the Baroque era). There’s even the Mouret fanfare made famous as the “Masterpiece Theater” theme music. Yes this is a great “introduction” at a great price – which might get people to explore Baroque music further, but it’s also a fairly complete collection which will suit a lot of people as such (i.e. for everyone who appreciates most any type of music these works should be “essential”, but also the 4 CD collection might be all that a casual listener would “need” from the Baroque era). I feel that most people would be thrilled with this set; about the only way it might have been better would be to include information about each piece and about the Baroque era in general (there is no “text” at all with this set).

3 of 10 people found the following review helpful.
Entry level baroque
By Conan The Republican
Nice cheap way to get into Baroque music. Unfortunately it’s not the best recording you can get but it should be adequate enough for a non-audiophile. I’ve been unable to bring myself to listening to it again since I noticed that someone coughs in the background (very noticeably) during Handel’s Messiah. Wonder if this is an outtakes CD.

See all 2 customer reviews…